Police: Overtime is Out of Our Control

Chief Borden reflects on change to ordinance, eliminating three vacant positions.

After having the total number of police officers reduced from 78 to 77 in 2008, the Bridgewater Township Police Department has become accustomed to making due with fewer personnel.

And now, after making cuts to the municipal budget to , the council has opted to introduce an .

“The positions have not been filled since the initiation of the ordinance, so we have adjusted our schedule to working without the three officers,” Chief Richard Borden said.

According to Borden, the council originally approved an ordinance in September 2008 that allowed for the funding of three more officers, but required approval before the department could hire them. Now the ordinance may be changed to eliminate the possibility of hiring those three.

“We could only hire with the approval of the mayor, and obviously due to budget constraints, we at this time have not received approval to hire any new officers,” he said. “We only have replacement officers due to retirement.”

In 2008, just before the ordinance was approved Borden said, a first lieutenant retired, bringing the total number of officers down to 77. That position, he said, was then eliminated and the person was not replaced.

Then, in 2009 Borden said, two more officers retired who were not replaced, bringing the number down to 75. The number was reduced again to 74 when an officer was laid off in 2010.

With that reduction in staff, the department has had to end the DARE program, as well as other school-based initiatives, Borden said.

“Due to budgetary constraints, we have not been authorized to hire any additional officers other than replacements, thus causing the vacating of the D.A.R.E. program and second school resource officer,” he said. “This was accomplished to maintain minimum levels of staffing in the patrol division.”

Mayor Dan Hayes said this ordinance itself has no real impact on the budget, only on the flexibility of officers in the township.

“I think that reduces the township’s flexibility, but we understood those conditions weren’t going to be funded,” he said. “If we need to put those officers back, we will ask the council again. If we find we need those positions, we will go right back to the council and ask them to change the ordinance.”

But the issue of overtime is the bigger concern for the police department because it is not predictable, Borden said.

At Monday’s township council meeting, Councilman Matthew Moench said he would be more in favor of hiring additional police officers to lessen the need for officers to work overtime, which often costs more because it goes to more senior officers.

But Borden said overtime cannot be determined in advance.

“Overtime is a dynamic situation,” he said. “Weather emergencies, serious accidents, violent crimes all factor into overtime because, in most cases other than in some weather incidents, you have no warning of the occurrence.”

In addition, officers and supervisors out of work for medical issues can factor into overtime as well, Borden said.

Sometimes grants can cover overtime costs, such as in the case of the DWI enforcements, but it will not cover those that are related to weather conditions like Hurricane Irene, Borden said.

“A homicide investigation could cause numerous hours of overtime and court appearances,” he said. “Our jurisdiction may not have a homicide investigation all year, or you could have the opposite occurring where several homicides occur in a given year.”

And in those cases, officers have to appear in court for testimony, which affects overtime, Borden said.

“A long protracted trial could add to the overtime costs during a calendar year,” he said.

For the most part, Borden said, overtime cannot be totally eliminated in a 365-day job. For example, he said, if a serious motor vehicle accident occurs on Route 22 at rush hour, day shift personnel could be required to stay at the scene for traffic control.

“If a serious crime occurs an hour prior to an officer securing for the evening, the officer may be forced to stay to secure the scene or to interview witnesses or formulate a report that must be forwarded in a certain time frame,” he said.

Because of all that, Borden said, the department attempts to manage overtime as best as possible, while understanding the budgetary constraints that prevent additional officers from being hired.

“It is our responsibility as administrators and supervisors to manage overtime as best we can,” he said. “There are definitely situations that can be managed, and other situations that are reactive and out of your control.”

Gary May 10, 2012 at 07:02 PM
Mr. Moench indicates he would rather "hire" than pay overtime due to it's cost effectiveness. Please, help me understand, what the long term liability (aka severence) of a public servant cost the tax payer. I think you will find the guarenteed benefits have a huge net present value well and above the one time hit over time impacts the budge. I would hope as a council member this myopia is not embedded in the decision making of the council. Moreover, if there is a concern over force reductions I would be curious to know the effect that force reduction has had relative to violent crime. My guess is from the reading local papers, not much.
Hunter Thompson June 16, 2012 at 12:48 AM
Force reductions should be an automatic. A trip to are very ostentatious court house is my first example. There seems to be a multitude of officers there whose sole purpose is to hold up the walls. Two officers checking you at the metal detector, one acting as doorman, two or more as ushers in the court. I mean really! A quick look at the police blotter is further prove. Invariably the arrests consist of DWI's. Where is all this major crime that warrant's such a massive police force. As for overtime, how about getting them to work, when they are on straight time. If I see another officer flying around town(generally on a cell phone), I swear to god. They really did use excessive speed. Or they are just parked somewhere(again on the cell phone). I always look in the paper when I see four officers pulling over a car, etc. My thought on this is something major must have happened, right? Wrong? I never find anything in the paper. Truth is they just didn't have anything better to do. SCAFIBS


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »